Advertisement

newsPublic Safety

Why are police in a North Texas city taking photos of people they pull over?

A criminal justice professor said the practice likely falls in a legal gray area.

Ian Pearce was driving to work early one morning in September 2021 when he spotted flashing police lights behind him.

Pearce, who worked as an Arlington teacher at the time, realized he was absentmindedly speeding and pulled into a parking lot along Pioneer Parkway in Pantego.

To his surprise, the officer let him go with a warning. But he was unsettled by what followed.

Advertisement

“I’m just going to take your picture real quick,” Pearce recalled the officer saying, as he snapped his photo with an electronic ticket machine. The officer explained it was standard procedure.

Breaking News

Get the latest breaking news from North Texas and beyond.

Or with:

Police in Pantego — a tiny town almost entirely surrounded by Arlington — have for years taken photos of drivers who receive even minor traffic violations. Criminal justice and legal experts say the policy, though likely not illegal, could prompt concerns over security and privacy.

“This is definitely not standard practice,” said Johnny Nhan, a criminal justice professor at TCU. “Is it legal? I would say it falls in a gray area.”

Advertisement

Photos are used to ensure identities of people who contest tickets in court or do not pay fines and are arrested, Police Chief Jon Coulter said. Previously, he said, people often used names and birth dates of family members, and warrants were issued for the wrong people. Coulter did not say why a driver’s license or other state-issued ID is not sufficient proof.

Like many small towns, Pantego — which has a population of roughly 2,500 — uses traffic fines to fund a considerable portion of its budget. In 2022, police issued about 4,000 traffic citations. This year, the city expects to collect nearly $610,000 in fines, accounting for more than 12% of its budget.

Advertisement

In 2019, a report by Governing found Pantego was one of roughly 600 U.S. cities in which punitive fines account for more than 10% of revenue. That list also included Pantego’s neighbor Dalworthington Gardens.

After he was pulled over, Pearce, 39, who lives in Arlington, said he wondered where his photo was being stored, how it might be used and whether it was secure.

“The picture was just sprung on me,” he said. “I didn’t question it at the time, but I was surprised.”

The Larry W. Smith Law Enforcement Center in Pantego, Texas, Wednesday, Jan. 25, 2023.
The Larry W. Smith Law Enforcement Center in Pantego, Texas, Wednesday, Jan. 25, 2023.(Elías Valverde II / Staff Photographer)

Per the city’s policy, photos should only be taken when tickets are issued, but two people, including Pearce, told The Dallas Morning News their photographs were taken despite not getting a ticket.

Photos are uploaded directly to the Pantego municipal court’s secure computer system, Coulter said, where they remain for five years before being deleted.

Although nothing in state or federal law prohibits police from taking or storing the photos, the practice could simply make people uncomfortable, said Geoffrey Corn, chair of criminal law for Texas Tech University’s law school.

“Ultimately, this is up to people and to lawmakers to decide,” he said. “Just because something is permissible doesn’t mean we as a society want it.”

Advertisement

Nhan, the TCU professor, said police must have reasonable grounds for capturing fingerprints, and he sees some parallels between the two. Additionally, he questioned the added usefulness of photographs.

“We already have driver’s licenses, Real ID photos,” he said. “Why take everyone’s picture?”